Last updated: 2025-05-06
Best Upscale Restaurants in San Mateo
San Mateo’s culinary landscape offers a refined dining experience that blends Silicon Valley sophistication with Bay Area creativity. From intimate wine bars to innovative restaurants, the city’s dining scene reflects its cosmopolitan character and diverse culinary influences.
Local restaurants like Pausa Bar & Cookery and Aventra showcase the region’s commitment to exceptional cuisine, featuring locally sourced ingredients and expertly crafted dishes that capture the essence of San Mateo’s vibrant food culture.
Discover San Mateo’s most exquisite dining destinations now!
Featured Fine Dining Spots in San Mateo
- Porterhouse
- Pausa Bar & Cookery
- Central Park Bistro
- Iron Gate (Belmont)
- Avenida
- Selby's (Menlo Park)
- Izakaya Ginji
- The Barrel Bistro & Wine Bar
- Vespucci Ristorante Italiano
- All Spice
All Spice
What to Expect
Seasonal Modern Californian cuisine in a converted cottage
Description
Nestled in a charming cottage, All Spice offers an intimate Modern Californian dining experience featuring seasonally curated menus. The restaurant provides an elegant, boutique atmosphere with carefully crafted three-course dining experiences served Tuesday through Saturday evenings in a cozy, personalized setting.
Restaurant Details
More Info: All Spice ↗
Avenida
What to Expect
Modern Filipino cuisine inspired by historic Manila streetscape
Description
Avenida offers an authentic modern Filipino bar and grill experience, drawing inspiration from the vibrant Avenida Rizal in Old Manila. The restaurant celebrates Philippine culinary heritage through a contemporary lens, featuring Art Deco-influenced design and a menu that reimagines traditional flavors with sophisticated urban flair.
Restaurant Details
More Info: Avenida ↗
Central Park Bistro
What to Expect
Impressive wine cellar with curated wine selection
Description
Central Park Bistro offers an elegant dining experience in downtown San Mateo, featuring contemporary American cuisine with sophisticated seasonal dishes. The restaurant boasts an impressive wine cellar and an intimate atmosphere, serving carefully crafted entrées like grilled Australian lamb chops and lobster linguini alongside signature items such as warm toffee bread pudding.
Restaurant Details
More Info: Central Park Bistro ↗
Iron Gate (Belmont)
What to Expect
Extensive wine cellar with award-winning international selections
Description
Nestled along El Camino Real, Iron Gate offers an intimate French Continental dining experience in a historic Peninsula restaurant. The candlelit dining rooms showcase carefully curated wines from France, Italy, and California, paired meticulously with sophisticated continental cuisine crafted by owners Dimitrios and Kaveh over three decades.
Restaurant Details
More Info: Iron Gate ↗
Izakaya Ginji
What to Expect
Tableside QR code menu and ordering system
Description
A contemporary Japanese izakaya featuring globally inspired dishes and modern culinary techniques. The restaurant offers an innovative dining experience with tableside QR code ordering, signature items like Mentaiko Carbonara and Ginji Lion King Roll, and a casual yet sophisticated atmosphere blending traditional Japanese comfort cooking with creative interpretations.
Restaurant Details
More Info: Izakaya Ginji ↗
Pausa Bar & Cookery
What to Expect
Handcrafted Italian small plates with California ingredient focus
Description
Nestled in downtown San Mateo, Pausa Bar & Cookery offers an intimate Italian-inspired dining experience with an open kitchen and craft cocktail bar. Seasonal California ingredients transform into sophisticated small plates and handmade pastas, served in a warmly lit, contemporary space with wood accents and an inviting chef's counter.
Restaurant Details
More Info: Pausa Bar & Cookery ↗
Porterhouse
What to Expect
Visible meat locker with in-house dry-aging process
Description
Housed in a historic 1924 bank building, Porterhouse offers an elevated steakhouse experience with dry-aged Midwest beef, tableside French-inspired preparations like Bananas Foster, and an acclaimed wine list featuring Napa Valley and international selections. High-ceilinged dining rooms adorned with Golden Age Hollywood memorabilia create an inviting atmosphere for romantic dinners and special occasions.
Restaurant Details
More Info: Porterhouse ↗
Selby's (Menlo Park)
What to Expect
Art deco-inspired fine dining with seasonal California cuisine
Description
Nestled in downtown Menlo Park, Selby's offers an intimate fine dining experience with an elegant art deco-inspired dining room. The restaurant features seasonal California cuisine prepared with meticulous precision, served in a sophisticated setting with white-glove service and an extensive wine selection curated by expert sommeliers.
Restaurant Details
More Info: Selby's ↗
The Barrel Bistro & Wine Bar
What to Expect
Weekend bottomless mimosa brunch with live classic rock music
Description
Nestled in downtown San Mateo, this sophisticated wine bar and bistro offers an intimate dining experience with an extensive wine selection, craft cocktails, and a seasonal menu featuring seafood and charcuterie. The restaurant boasts an inviting interior and a festive outdoor patio with live music on weekends, creating a vibrant atmosphere for dining and socializing.
Restaurant Details
More Info: The Barrel Bistro & Wine Bar ↗
Vespucci Ristorante Italiano
What to Expect
Family recipes from Calabrian and Neapolitan culinary traditions
Description
A family-owned Italian restaurant in San Mateo celebrating authentic regional cuisine from Calabria and Naples. Intimate dining room features traditional recipes passed down through generations, with ingredients imported directly from Italy and a menu highlighting fresh, seasonal specialties crafted by owners Francesco and Manuela.
Restaurant Details
More Info: Vespucci Ristorante Italiano ↗
Your Ultimate Guide
Dive deeper with our comprehensive guide, packed with tips, insights, and everything you need to know.
San Mateo Fine Dining News
Stay updated with the latest fine dining trends and exceptional restaurants in your area
View Latest NewsSan Mateo Fine Dining Discussion
Welcome to the discussion We invite you to discuss and share your thoughts about fine dining spots and culinary experiences in San Mateo
Join the San Mateo Discussion!Find Fine Dining in Other Cities
Looking for fine dining in another city?
Fine Dining Mailing List
Our Quality Assurance Process
Every restaurant listing goes through our comprehensive review process combining industry expertise with customer feedback. We maintain unbiased listings (except for clearly marked featured restaurants) to ensure you get accurate, reliable fine dining information.
Have questions about our process or want to learn more? We'd love to hear from you! Contact us